top of page
City of Burnaby

Water Metering: LTE Vs. RF Vs. TouchPad

Burnaby wanted water meters read accurately without tying up its most skilled people. We looked at tech that brought efficiencies.

What was the challenge?

Burnaby wanted every water meter read accurately and in real time, without tying up its most skilled people. Meters were read two ways: touchpad, which meant crews walking up to each one, and RF drive-by, which was patchy and missed reads. Some of the people doing the touchpad work were senior, ticketed plumbers who spent most of their time on meter routes instead of plumbing. Spotty reads meant missed revenue, and nobody had real-time data on usage or leaks. Engineering wanted to move to an AMI system, starting with commercial accounts and eventually reaching every water account in the city.

What we did on the ground

We started by riding along. Foremen and senior staff took us through the routes and showed us how each technology behaved in real conditions, where it worked, and where crews were still doing things by hand.

Then we set up a range test, LTE against RF. We drew on our own radio background, including licensed amateur radio experience and years working with IoT companies, to ask a practical question: if a radio sits high on city infrastructure, how wide a swath of Burnaby can it read? We tested from the Laurel works yard and City Hall.

RF covered a decent range, but not consistently. Like a drive-by, you couldn't be sure every meter got picked up, and you'd only find the gaps after the fact. RF is also one-way, so a meter can be heard but can't answer back. Cellular works both ways. It carries far more data per meter, and the meter can check in on its own. It does mean carrier subscriptions, but the instant information could offset the upfront cost.

We also explored a what-if: put mobile readers on vehicles the city already runs, like garbage trucks and other fleet, so meters are constantly being scanned and rescanned. On paper it's neat. In practice it means a lot of duplicate data, the readers are expensive, and reads arrive on the vehicle's schedule instead of in real time.

Outcomes

The comparison laid out what each approach could and couldn't do, and that went into a business case for Council. The business case opened the door to an RFP for a smaller initial deployment. Burnaby now has a tested path from labour-heavy reads toward real-time metering, with evidence behind it.

Development Application Intake Redesign

City of Burnaby

Fleet Telematics and Smart Routing

City of Burnaby

Smart Waste Receptacles

City of Burnaby

More projects

Let's walk it together

We spend time where the work happens, listening to your team and watching the process as it really runs.

Book a site walk
bottom of page